( While still on guard, hands hovering by his hips, Sam's eyebrows dip in confusion at the lack of recognition from the other man. ) Yeah... we've met. ( Sam doesn't remember Benny being quite this talkative, honestly, but it isn't like they spent a lot of time together. All Sam knew about him was what Dean told him, and Sam had taken everything he'd said with a grain of salt. Trust was in low supply between them in those days.
Still, even though it makes no sense that Benny doesn't know him, other than that, his story sounds an awful lot like Sam's own - minus a few key details. ) You were... in Purgatory? ( Sam knows that Benny gave himself up to the monsters in Purgatory so Dean could excape - and there's a twinge of guilt there, because it should have been Sam who got him out, as Dean has always made clear - but that was after they had met. )
Were you with Dean? ( Sam isn't relaxing anytime soon, and he's not letting Benny leave until they've sorted out if the other man still has a taste for human blood - but Dean is the priority. He always has been. )
@tataille
Still, even though it makes no sense that Benny doesn't know him, other than that, his story sounds an awful lot like Sam's own - minus a few key details. ) You were... in Purgatory? ( Sam knows that Benny gave himself up to the monsters in Purgatory so Dean could excape - and there's a twinge of guilt there, because it should have been Sam who got him out, as Dean has always made clear - but that was after they had met. )
Were you with Dean? ( Sam isn't relaxing anytime soon, and he's not letting Benny leave until they've sorted out if the other man still has a taste for human blood - but Dean is the priority. He always has been. )